With legal ethics in the national spotlight, this first-of-its-kind, AI-assisted investigation reveals an attorney discipline system that is secretive, inconsistent, unfair, and obsessed with the "business of law." The same AI, the book argues, holds the promise to reinvent attorney discipline and the justice system itself.
The Massachusetts Board of Bar Overseers promises "to protect the public from unethical conduct by attorneys." In a typical year, it "resolves" 96% of the complaints it receives without opening an investigation, usually within 45 days and never with a written explanation.
In Slot Machine Justice, a physician, healthcare analyst, and analytics entrepreneur uses AI to examine 24 years of attorney-discipline decisions in Massachusetts. By turning more than 4,000 unstructured legal decisions into a structured dataset, he asks a simple question: does the disciplinary system do what it claims?
The answer reads less like blind justice and more like a slot machine.
Similar misconduct produces wildly different outcomes. Mitigating factors, aggravating factors, conditions, and other case characteristics are inconsistently associated with the final sanction. The institution charged with protecting the public focuses heavily on the mechanics of running a practice-bookkeeping most of all-while substantive legal ethics play a far smaller role. Counting only the most serious sanctions-suspension or worse, for legal misconduct arising in Massachusetts-discipline reaches a lawyer roughly once per thousand years of practice.
The author came to the project as both an analyst and a defendant. While facing a federal criminal case of his own, he went looking for how similar cases had been resolved-and found that the justice system, despite the mountains of documents it generates, had never organized those documents into something ordinary people could use. Attorney discipline became the proof of concept: with the help of AI, thousands of scattered legal records are transformed into a structured dataset of how a system actually behaves.
But this book is about far more than one disciplinary board. It is a blueprint for the future of the legal system itself.
The same AI that exposed these patterns can be applied to the courts, moving the law away from adversarial gamesmanship and toward data-driven improvement. The author proposes concrete next steps for improving both attorney discipline and the judicial system.
Part personal narrative, part data sleuthing, and part public-accountability investigation, Slot Machine Justice does not ask readers to take its conclusions on faith. Hundreds of cited cases let them check the work themselves.
A citizen with data held an institution accountable. This story shows what he found, how he measured it, and how the same approach could finally make the justice system answerable to the people it serves.
外文書商品之書封，為出版社提供之樣本。實際出貨商品，以出版社所提供之現有版本為主。部份書籍，因出版社供應狀況特殊，匯率將依實際狀況做調整。
無庫存之商品，在您完成訂單程序之後，將以空運的方式為你下單調貨。為了縮短等待的時間，建議您將外文書與其他商品分開下單，以獲得最快的取貨速度，平均調貨時間為1~2個月。
為了保護您的權益，「三民網路書店」提供會員七日商品鑑賞期(收到商品為起始日)。
若要辦理退貨，請在商品鑑賞期內寄回，且商品必須是全新狀態與完整包裝(商品、附件、發票、隨貨贈品等)否則恕不接受退貨。
